Friday, May 09, 2008

Now She's Wallace!


More and more commentators are bringing heat on Hillary for her "hard working white" comments. This is from the (pretty liberal) Joe Conason at the Huffington Post:
Citing an Associated Press analysis "that found how Senator Obama's support among working, hard-working Americans, white Americans, is weakening again, and how whites in both states who had not completed college were supporting me," she went on to say: "There's a pattern emerging here."

There is indeed a pattern emerging -- and it is a pattern that must dismay everyone who admires the Clintons and has defended them against the charge that they are exploiting racial divisions.

As Sean Wilentz and others have argued, there was no ugly subtext to her innocuous remark about the different roles of Martin Luther King Jr. and Lyndon Baines Johnson in the civil rights crusade, although several prominent Obama supporters promoted that smear. And if Bill Clinton's comparison of Obama and Jesse Jackson was badly timed and clumsy, that too fell within the bounds of acceptable commentary. Indeed, the discussion of ethnic and racial voting preferences is not only fair but unavoidable and utterly mundane in American politics.

But this time she violated the rhetorical rules, no doubt by mistake. It was her offhand reference to "working, hard-working Americans, white Americans" that raises the specter of old Dixie demagogues like Wallace and Lester Maddox. Was she dog-whistling to the voters of Kentucky and West Virginia?
Conason, by aligning himself with the loopy Wilentz, shows that he doesn't entirely get the depravity of Hillary... yet even he recognizes the George Wallace-ness of Hillary. It's as if she's completed the transformation of Nixon and is pursuing her own Southern Strategy.

h/t TPM, photo from Wiki.

No comments: